Hi, if you want free updates from my blog, you can enter your email address here.

I’m Asking You – Are Threaded Comments Useful?



In the early days of Legal Andrew (over a year ago!), I was lucky to get one comment per week. Thanks to you guys, comments now abound. I love it, and I hope you guys do too.

Now I’m wondering if the standard list of comments is inadequate for our conversations. I try to respond to most comments, and sometimes we end up with a multiple-comment interchange. As you’ve seen, it’s not abnormal to get 10 or more comments on a post.

You’re probably thinking that really popular blogs gets dozens, if not hundreds, of comments per post. That’s absolutely true. And some of them use threaded comments (like John and Matt).

Threaded comments

I’m thinking of trying out the Yet Another Threaded Comments plugin. You can see it in action at Perfume Posse (yes, it’s an odd site).

The reviews of this plugin seem pretty positive, and I think I can get it to look similar to the current comment layout. Also, it doesn’t use JavaScript, like the more popular plugin, Brian’s Threaded Comments.

What do you think?

Before I make a change like this, I need your input. After all, I write for you guys. I’d appreciate your vote through this poll. (RSS readers will probably need to click through to see it.)

The poll should show up here, or you can see it in the sidebar, right under my face. :)

{democracy:4}

If you have any additional thoughts, please leave a comment. I look forward to more great conversations with you guys!

[tags]threaded comments, conversations[/tags]

Get more legal tips

Sign-up below to receive my bi-monthly email newsletter with free legal tips. All fields are required.





See also...

Comments

5 Responses to “I’m Asking You – Are Threaded Comments Useful?”

  1. Brett McKay
    May 24th, 2007

    They’re kind of trippy. Maybe it was just the site’s color scheme. I can see how they can be useful, though. I think it might be a little hard for me to adjust to the different comment layout.

  2. Andrew Flusche
    May 24th, 2007

    Brett,

    Trippy! That’s a great assessment. The purple shades on my example site do trip me out a bit. I tried to find a better example, but I had no luck.

    I see your point about adjusting to the layout, especially when 99% of blogs just do the standard method.

    Thanks for the input,
    Andrew

  3. Pro Se Thoughts
    May 25th, 2007

    I prefer threaded comments but if you end up with a lot of comments on a page, the original post will take longer to load won’t it? Some of us are in the sticks and still use *choke* dial-up, *blush* to access the Internet. I like reading comments, but WordPress seems to slow down with too many of them. Maybe it’s just my dial up?

    I use IntegraMod for dealing with lengthy comment discussions. My blog isn’t well known right now, so I don’t have to worry about a lot of comments, but if it takes off, I’ve set up a place where discussions can be managed better, and a certain blog consultant (I hope) will help me figure out how to link my blog posts to the related discussion site. *grin*

    Andrew, if you can find a WordPress plugin that integrates with IntegraMod discussions, that would be very cool. Here’s what my law discussion threaded messages look like, but I would love to tie this in with the blog some how: http://www.globalide.com/index.php

    Whatever solution you find for your blog, you know I’m going to want it on my blog too! I use your blog features to keep up to date for my own. I also like whatever you’re using to send blog posts through our email, and I like the survey poll you just embedded. I’ll add them to the blog to do list.

  4. Andrew Flusche
    May 25th, 2007

    Hi Pro Se,

    I definitely see your point about comments increasing page load times. The message board idea is one solution. Steve Pavlina has gone that route. Another method is to use paged comments. Then only the first 20-25 comments load with the original post, the rest are put onto page 2,3,etc.

    I’m going to keep my eye on the poll and see what the overall vote is. We’ll see if I end up making a change.

    Andrew

  5. jfe
    August 14th, 2007

    Very nice work, admin :) Good luck!i

Comments are automatically closed on older posts.

  • Legal tips by email

    Sign-up below to get email tips and exclusive discounts on videos, webinars, and future items.

    All fields are required.





  • Receive updates

    By email
    By rss (full feed)
  • About Andrew Flusche

    Lawyer, bicyclist, husband.
    More about me...
    Tumble Log
    View Andrew Flusche's profile on LinkedIn
    Andrew Flusche's Facebook Profile
  • Popular Posts